Handel’s Homemade Ice Cream Menu With Prices (Updated October 2026)
Handel’s Homemade Ice Cream Menu With Prices (Updated October 2026)
Handel’s Homemade Ice Cream started in Youngstown, Ohio, in 1945, when Alice Handel began selling ice cream made with fresh fruit from her husband’s gas station. Eight decades later, the brand still makes its ice cream fresh in every store, every day. If you are looking for the Handel’s Homemade Ice Cream menu with prices, this guide (updated October 2026) pulls it together — hurricanes, sundaes, cones and dishes, pints and quarts, the famous flavor lineup, typical prices, hours, deals, and answers to common questions.
Handel’s is famous for two things: the sheer number of flavors (more than 140 rotate through the year) and the Hurricane, a thick blended treat that rivals any shake on the market. The prices below are the most commonly listed in-store prices from recent menus. Heads-up: delivery apps list the same items higher, and individual stores set their own prices. Delivery and catering prices are listed on the official website too.
Handel’s Homemade Ice Cream Menu With Prices — Most Popular Items
Hurricanes and the scoop sampler do the heavy lifting at Handel’s, with the banana split as the classic splurge. Here are the most popular items and their typical prices:
| Item | Price |
|---|---|
| Hurricane | $3.75+ |
| Scoop Sampler | $5.00 |
| Banana Split | $5.75 |
| Sundae | $4.00 |
| Waffle Cone | $4.00+ |
| Cone or Dish | $3.25+ |
| Handel Pops | $2.50 |
| Ice Cream Favorite | $4.50+ |
Handel’s Homemade Ice Cream Menu With Prices — Full Menu
The menu below is organized by category. Store prices vary, as always.
Hurricanes
The Hurricane is Handel’s signature blended treat: your choice of ice cream spun thick with candy or cookie mix-ins. It drinks like a shake but eats like soft-serve. These are the most popular Hurricane flavors — the Oreo one has a cult following.
| Item | Price |
|---|---|
| Butterfinger Hurricane | $3.75+ |
| Oreo Hurricane | $3.75+ |
| Reese’s Pieces Hurricane | $3.75+ |
| M&M Hurricane | $3.75+ |
| Snickers Hurricane | $3.75+ |
| Heath Hurricane | $3.75+ |
| Cookie Dough Hurricane | $3.75+ |
| Nerds Hurricane | $3.75+ |
| Cotton Candy Hurricane | $3.75+ |
| Fish Bait Hurricane | $3.75+ |
| On The Moon Hurricane | $3.75+ |
Delivery apps list medium Hurricanes around $7.93 to $9.70 and large around $9.15 to $10.98, but those include the delivery markup. In store, a Hurricane starts at $3.75 and goes up with size. The gap between app and counter pricing is one of the biggest in ice cream — order at the window.
Cones & Dishes
Straight scoops in a cone or a dish. The waffle cone is made fresh in store and costs a little more than a standard cone — the smell alone sells it.
| Item | Price |
|---|---|
| Cone or Dish | $3.25+ |
| Waffle Cone | $4.00+ |
| Extra Cone | $0.25+ |
| Scoop Sampler | $5.00 |
| Handel Pops | $2.50 |
The Scoop Sampler is the smart order if you cannot pick a flavor: several small scoops so you can taste across the case. Indecisive? This was made for you.
Sundaes & Ice Cream Favorites
Sundaes come with your choice of topping, and the Ice Cream Favorites are the loaded builds. The banana split is the biggest thing on the dessert menu — a commitment, but a delicious one.
| Item | Price |
|---|---|
| Sundae | $4.00 |
| Ice Cream Favorite | $4.50+ |
| Banana Split | $5.75 |
Pints & Quarts To Go
Hand-packed pints and quarts take the daily-made flavors home. Multi-packs are the value play for stocking the freezer.
| Item | Price |
|---|---|
| Pint | $8.24 – $10.92 |
| Quart | $12.51 – $17.02 |
| 4-Pack of Pints | $31.11 – $41.36 |
| Medium Dish | $7.26 – $8.48 |
These ranges come from current delivery listings, which run higher than the counter. Expect in-store pints to sit at the lower end of the range — sometimes well below it.
The Flavor Lineup
Handel’s rotates more than 140 flavors through the year, made fresh in store daily. Regulars watch for Graham Central Station (graham cracker ice cream with a graham cracker swirl and chocolate-covered crunch), Mint Chocolate Chip, Chocolate Pecan, Buckeye, Blue Monster (blue moon ice cream with chocolate chips), Deep Dish Apple Pie, and Black Raspberry Chunk. Seasonal flavors like peppermint and pumpkin roll in for the holidays. Every shop also carries no-sugar-added and sherbet options.
Handel’s Homemade Ice Cream Coupons & Deals
Handel’s runs a loyalty program through its app, with points on every purchase and a birthday reward. The brand is famous for its free ice cream promotions — it has given away free scoops on National Ice Cream Day and for other celebrations, drawing long lines at participating shops. Follow your local shop on social media for flavor drops and flash deals. Delivery apps sometimes discount Handel’s orders, but the counter price is always lowest. The handel’s homemade ice cream menu with prices helps you spot which deal actually saves the most. The handel’s homemade ice cream menu with prices above covers the most-ordered items.
Handel’s Homemade Ice Cream Nutrition & Calories
Nutrition facts for Handel’s flavors and treats are published on the company website. Because the ice cream is made fresh daily with cream and sugar, it is a full-flavor treat — the small sizes and the no-sugar-added flavors are the lighter options. Hurricanes add calories fast because of the candy mix-ins, so splitting a large one is a reasonable move. Or don’t. We don’t judge.
Handel’s Homemade Ice Cream Hours
Most Handel’s shops open around 11:00 am or noon and close between 9:00 and 10:00 pm. Many locations are seasonal in colder markets and may close or shorten hours in winter. Check your local shop before visiting — drive-thru times can run later than the dining room. The handel’s homemade ice cream menu with prices covers both.
Handel’s Homemade Ice Cream Menu FAQs
What is a Hurricane at Handel’s?
A: Handel’s signature blended treat — ice cream spun thick with your choice of candy or cookie mix-ins, starting at $3.75 in store. Think Blizzard, but made with fresh-daily ice cream. The handel’s homemade ice cream menu with prices above lists it with the current price.
How much is a banana split at Handel’s?
A: The banana split is $5.75 at most locations. For a three-scoop build with toppings, that’s genuinely reasonable.
How many flavors does Handel’s have?
A: More than 140 flavors rotate through the year, made fresh in each store daily. The daily board changes, so no two visits look exactly alike — which is exactly why regulars keep coming back. You can find the current lineup on the handel’s homemade ice cream menu with prices near the top of this page.
What is the cheapest item at Handel’s?
A: Handel Pops are $2.50, and a basic cone or dish starts at $3.25. For a chain that makes everything fresh daily, those are friendly numbers.
Does Handel’s make its ice cream fresh?
A: Yes — every shop makes its ice cream fresh on-site daily, a practice going back to 1945. It’s the whole brand promise, and they still keep it.
Does Handel’s have dairy-free options?
A: Shops carry sorbets and no-sugar-added flavors. Ask what is on the board that day — the rotation means the options change.
Getting the Best Value at Handel’s
The Hurricane starting at $3.75 is the value headline — a thick blended treat for less than most shops charge for a plain shake. The Scoop Sampler at $5.00 is the taster’s deal: multiple flavors for the price of a single sundae elsewhere. A basic cone or dish at $3.25 is the cheapest way into the case. Pints to go are the freezer play, but compare the in-store pint price against the delivery listings ($8.24 to $10.92) — the counter is always lower. Handel’s famous free-scoop promotions on National Ice Cream Day and similar events are worth watching for; follow your local shop so you hear about them before the lines form.
Bookmark this page — the handel’s homemade ice cream menu with prices makes it easy to compare items side by side. Give it one more look before you order so there are no surprises at the register. Then get the Hurricane.
Related Menus
- Bruster’s Real Ice Cream Menu With Prices
- Graeter’s Menu With Prices
- Marble Slab Creamery Menu With Prices
- Cold Stone Creamery Menu With Prices
