Potbelly Menu With Prices (Updated October 2026)
Potbelly Menu With Prices (Updated October 2026)
Potbelly started in 1977 as a Chicago antique shop that sold toasted sandwiches on the side. The sandwiches won — today the chain runs about 450 shops nationwide. This potbelly menu with prices guide, updated October 2026, lists real current prices for toasted sandwiches, hand-dipped shakes, soups, salads, Pick-Your-Pair combos, and more — plus catering, hours, and the questions people ask most. Prices may vary by location. An Original-size sandwich ran about $12.39–$13.69 in recent checks.
People look up Potbelly prices because the sizes have names: Skinny, Original, and BIG — and the price jumps between them. A Wreck in Original runs about $12.99. The hand-dipped shakes are a real draw too, at $6.29–$7.19. Everything comes toasted, which sets Potbelly apart from the cold-sub shops.
Potbelly Menu With Prices — Most Popular Items
A Wreck, the Italian, and Turkey Breast are the top three sandwiches. The OREO shake is the most-ordered shake.
| Item | Skinny | Original | BIG |
|---|---|---|---|
| A Wreck | $9.39 | $12.99 | $17.49 |
| Italian | $9.39 | $12.99 | $17.49 |
| Turkey Breast | $8.59 | $12.39 | $16.49 |
| Avo Turkey | $9.99 | $13.69 | $17.99 |
| Mediterra | $8.59 | $12.39 | $16.49 |
Potbelly Full Menu With Prices
Full menu below, sorted by category. Prices may vary by location. Skinny is the thin-bread build, Original is the standard, BIG doubles the meat.
Toasted Sandwiches
| Item | Skinny | Original | BIG |
|---|---|---|---|
| A Wreck (salami, roast beef, turkey, ham) | $9.39 | $12.99 | $17.49 |
| Italian (salami, capicola, mortadella, pepperoni) | $9.39 | $12.99 | $17.49 |
| Turkey Breast | $8.59 | $12.39 | $16.49 |
| Avo Turkey | $9.99 | $13.69 | $17.99 |
| Mediterra (chicken, artichoke, roasted peppers) | $8.59 | $12.39 | $16.49 |
| Clubby (turkey, ham, Swiss) | $8.59 | $12.39 | $16.49 |
| Mushroom Melt | $8.59 | $12.39 | $16.49 |
| Pizza Melt | $8.59 | $12.39 | $16.49 |
| Grilled Chicken & Cheddar | $8.99 | $12.79 | $16.99 |
| Farmhouse Chicken Salad | $8.59 | $12.39 | $16.49 |
A Wreck is the signature — four meats stacked and toasted. Going Skinny saves about $3.50 and cuts the bread, not the fillings.
Pick-Your-Pair
| Item | Price |
|---|---|
| Skinny Sandwich + Cup of Soup | $14.39 |
| Skinny Sandwich + Half Salad | $14.39 |
| Skinny Sandwich + Mac & Cheese Cup | $14.39 |
Pick-Your-Pair pairs a Skinny sandwich with soup, salad, or mac and cheese. The best value on the menu for a full lunch.
Soups & Mac
| Item | Price |
|---|---|
| Soup (cup) | $6.29 |
| Mac & Cheese (cup) | $6.29 |
Salads
| Item | Price |
|---|---|
| Chicken Salad | $9.39 |
| Grilled Chicken & Cheddar Salad | $9.39 |
| Mediterranean Salad | $9.39 |
| Powerhouse Salad | $9.39 |
Shakes
| Item | Price |
|---|---|
| Strawberry Shake | $6.29 |
| Chocolate Shake | $6.79 |
| Vanilla Shake | $6.79 |
| OREO Cookies & Cream Shake | $7.19 |
Potbelly shakes are hand-dipped with real ice cream. The OREO shake at $7.19 is the fan favorite.
Sides & Sweets
| Item | Price |
|---|---|
| Chips | $2.59 |
| Pickle Spear | $1.69 |
| Chocolate Chip Cookie | $2.89 |
| Oatmeal Chocolate Chip Cookie | $2.89 |
| Dream Bar | $3.19 |
Drinks & Beverages
| Item | Price |
|---|---|
| Fountain Drink | $2.99 |
| Bottled Soda | $4.29–$4.59 |
| Bottled Water | $2.99 |
| Fresh-Squeezed Lemonade | $3.49 |
Potbelly Catering Menu & Prices
Potbelly caters with sandwich platters, boxed lunches, salads, cookies, and drinks for groups. Catering prices aren’t published nationally and vary by market — order through the Potbelly website or call your local shop for a quote. Boxed lunches typically pair a sandwich with chips, a cookie, and a drink.
Keep this potbelly menu with prices open on your phone and the line moves faster. Know your size before you step up.
Skim the potbelly menu with prices once and the menu board won’t slow you down. The toaster line waits for no one.
Potbelly Hours
Most locations run 10:30 AM to 8:00 or 9:00 PM daily. Hours vary by shop; downtown locations often close earlier on weekends. Holiday hours change through the year.
The potbelly menu with prices helps big groups agree before they reach the counter. Settle the size debate at home.
This potbelly menu with prices leaves out test-market items you can’t order yet. What’s here is what’s actually on the menu.
The potbelly menu with prices answers the two big questions: what can I get, and what does it cost. Start with the size math — it drives everything.
Potbelly Menu With Prices FAQs
What is the most popular sandwich at Potbelly?
A: A Wreck — salami, roast beef, turkey, and ham, toasted. The signature order, and the one to try first.
What are Potbelly’s sandwich sizes?
A: Skinny (thin bread), Original (standard), and BIG (double meat). The price jumps about $4–$5 per step — the Skinny is the value play, the BIG is the appetite play.
Are Potbelly shakes good?
A: They’re hand-dipped with real ice cream — yes, they’re good. The OREO shake at $7.19 is the most popular, and it’s not close.
What is the cheapest lunch at Potbelly?
A: A Skinny Turkey Breast at $8.59, or a Pick-Your-Pair at $14.39 for a full meal. The pair is the better lunch if you’re actually hungry.
Does Potbelly offer catering?
A: Yes — platters, boxed lunches, and group orders. Check potbelly.com or your local shop for prices. The boxed lunches are the easy office order.
Do Potbelly prices vary by location?
A: Yes — prices shift by market, and delivery apps may run higher than in-store. Downtown shops tend to cost more.
Potbelly Perks & Ordering Tips
Potbelly runs the Potbelly Perks rewards program — points on every order toward free food, plus a birthday treat and surprise offers. The app handles ordering, payment, and rewards in one place.
Size strategy matters. The Skinny uses thin bread with the same fillings — you save about $3.50 versus the Original and cut a lot of bread. The BIG doubles the meat for about $4.50 more than the Original: the move for very hungry eaters or splitting.
The Pick-Your-Pair at $14.39 is the best value on the menu — a Skinny sandwich plus soup, salad, or mac and cheese beats buying the pieces separately. The shakes are hand-dipped with real ice cream; the OREO at $7.19 is the one regulars recommend to first-timers.
Every sandwich comes toasted. Want it extra crispy? Ask — the crew will leave it in the toaster longer. And the hot peppers are free; add them to any sandwich.
Potbelly Nutrition & Lighter Options
Potbelly posts full nutrition info online. The Skinny sandwiches are the lighter play — thin bread, same fillings, fewer calories than the Original. Salads and the Powerhouse salad keep things green.
Soups at $6.29 pair well with a Skinny for a balanced lunch. Skip the shake if you’re watching calories — the hand-dipped shakes are a treat, not a light option. The Pick-Your-Pair with salad is the balanced combo.
Value math: the Skinny saves about $3.50 over the Original. The Pick-Your-Pair at $14.39 beats buying a sandwich and soup separately. Perks members earn points toward free food on every order.
Potbelly started in 1977 as an antique shop on Chicago’s Lincoln Avenue. The owner started selling toasted sandwiches to customers, and the sandwiches took over. Live music was part of the early shops; the name comes from the potbelly stove that heated the original store. About 450 shops nationwide now.
You now have the complete potbelly menu with prices for October 2026. See this month’s specials on the official Potbelly site. Double-check prices and hours with your local store before you head out.
Related Menus
- Subway Menu With Prices
- Panera Bread Menu With Prices
- Jimmy John’s Menu With Prices
- Portillo’s Menu With Prices
