Andy’s Frozen Custard Menu With Prices (Updated October 2026)
Andy’s Frozen Custard Menu With Prices (Updated October 2026)
Andy’s Frozen Custard opened in Osage Beach, Missouri, in 1986 on a simple promise: frozen custard made fresh every hour. Around 150 shops across the Midwest and South later, it’s got a cult following for its concretes and a drive-thru-friendly menu. Want the Andy’s Frozen Custard menu with prices? This guide (updated October 2026) has it — concretes, jackhammers, sundaes and splits, shakes and malts, floats and sodas, typical prices, hours, deals, and the questions people actually ask. Skim the andy’s frozen custard menu with prices once more before you order; combos often beat buying items one by one.
These are the most commonly listed prices from recent shop menus. Here’s the nice surprise: Andy’s prices are refreshingly low for the quality — most treats land between $5 and $7. Delivery apps list the same items higher, so the drive-thru wins. And prices shift a bit by location, as always.
Andy’s Frozen Custard Menu With Prices — Most Popular Items
The concretes and the James Brownie Funky Jackhammer are the legendary orders — the ones people drive across town for. Here are the most popular items with typical prices:
| Item | Price |
|---|---|
| Andy’s Custom Concrete | $5.30 – $6.10 |
| Triple Chocolate Concrete | $5.80 – $6.00 |
| Butter Pecan Concrete | $6.10 – $6.20 |
| Bootdaddy Concrete | $5.39 – $6.20 |
| James Brownie Funky Jackhammer | $6.20 – $6.80 |
| Andy’s Hot Fudge Sundae | $5.40 – $6.50 |
| Shake | $5.00 – $6.40 |
| Andy’s Turtle Split | $6.90 |
Andy’s Frozen Custard Full Menu With Prices
Menu’s organized by category below. Prices nudge around by location — your shop’s board is the final word.
Concretes
The concrete is Andy’s signature: frozen custard blended thick with mix-ins, served with a spoon. Pick a house build or go BYO and invent your own — the Bootdaddy and Triple Chocolate are the famous house picks.
| Item | Price |
|---|---|
| Andy’s Custom Concrete | $5.30 – $6.10 |
| Triple Chocolate Concrete | $5.80 – $6.00 |
| Butter Pecan Concrete | $6.10 – $6.20 |
| Bootdaddy Concrete | $5.39 – $6.20 |
| Snowmonster Concrete | $6.00 |
| Mint Cookie Concrete | $7.00 |
| Apple Pie Concrete | $5.70 |
| Chocolate Concrete | $5.50 |
| Andy’s BYO Concrete | $6.20 |
Jackhammers
The Jackhammer is the other signature: custard with a hard chocolate shell cracked through it, plus mix-ins. The James Brownie Funky Jackhammer is the famous one — order it once and you’ll get it.
| Item | Price |
|---|---|
| James Brownie Funky Jackhammer | $6.20 – $6.80 |
| Texas 2-Step | $5.29 |
| The Rico Suave | $6.29 |
| Andy’s BYO Jackhammer | $6.30 |
| Jackhammer Turtle | $6.10 |
Sundaes & Splits
Sundaes in the custard-shop classics. The Ozark Turtle and the Stolen Brownie are the loaded builds; the Straw-Ana is the original, the one that started it all.
| Item | Price |
|---|---|
| Andy’s Custom Sundae | $4.70 – $6.10 |
| Andy’s Hot Fudge Sundae | $5.40 – $6.50 |
| Andy’s Hot Fudge Sundae with Pecans | $5.40 |
| Andy’s Ozark Turtle Sundae | $7.60 |
| Stolen Brownie Sundae | $6.60 |
| The Original Straw-Ana Sundae | $4.94 – $6.30 |
| Andy’s King Sundae | $3.40 |
| Andy’s Kids’ Sundae (12 & under) | $3.40 |
| Andy’s Turtle Split | $6.90 |
| Andy’s Banana Split | $5.20 – $6.29 |
Shakes, Malts, Freezes & Floats
Shakes and malts get blended with the fresh-hourly custard — you can taste the difference. Freezes mix custard with soda; floats are the old-fashioned kind, done right.
| Item | Price |
|---|---|
| Shake | $5.00 – $6.40 |
| Choco Express Shake | $6.20 |
| Strawberry Oreo Cookie Shake | $6.20 |
| Double Double Malt | $5.90 |
| Andy’s BYO Shakes & Malts | $5.20 |
| Root Beer or Cream Soda Freeze | $4.39 – $5.20 |
| Float with Vanilla Custard | $4.60 |
| Jackhammer Float | check in store |
Cones, Cups & To-Go
Plain custard by the scoop for the purists, and quarts to take home for later. The quarts are dangerously convenient.
| Item | Price |
|---|---|
| Scoops of Vanilla Custard | $2.40 |
| Cake Cones & Cups | $3.80 |
| Baked Waffle Cones | $5.90 |
| Quart Combo (to go) | $15.10 |
| Vanilla & Chocolate Custard Pints/Quarts | check in store |
| Hand-Dipped Custard Bars | check in store |
| Zarlengo’s Italian Ice | check in store |
Drinks & Sodas
Old-fashioned sodas on tap and simple drinks. Nothing complicated — just cold and fizzy alongside your custard.
| Item | Price |
|---|---|
| Sprecher Soda on Tap | $1.80 – $2.50 |
| Bottled Soda | $2.80 |
| Fountain Drinks | check in store |
| Fresh Brewed Iced Tea | $1.40 – $1.50 |
| Bottled Water | check in store |
Andy’s Frozen Custard Menu With Prices — Coupons & Deals
Andy’s runs the Yum Squad rewards program — points on purchases, birthday treats, the usual good stuff. The app carries rotating offers and new-concrete announcements. Shops do seasonal concrete drops, so watch for limited flavors. Many locations honor military discounts with ID, which is a nice touch. Delivery apps run their own discounts, but the drive-thru price is lowest. The official Andy’s Frozen Custard site lists current promotions and new menu drops. Keep the andy’s frozen custard menu with prices on your phone so you know the going rates before you walk in.
Andy’s Frozen Custard Nutrition & Calories
Nutrition facts are published on the Andy’s website. Heads-up: frozen custard is richer than ice cream thanks to the egg yolk, so the small sizes are the lighter play. Concretes with candy mix-ins add up fast — the BYO concrete with fruit is the lighter build. Ask about the nutrition guide in store if you want the full numbers.
Andy’s Hours
Most Andy’s shops open at 11:00 am daily. Typical hours: Monday through Thursday 11:00 am to 11:30 pm, Friday and Saturday 11:00 am to midnight, Sunday 11:00 am to 11:30 pm. Hours vary by location, of course. And the andy’s frozen custard menu with prices changes through the year as seasonal items come and go.
Andy’s Frozen Custard Menu FAQs
What is the most popular item at Andy’s?
A: The concretes — especially the Bootdaddy and Triple Chocolate — and the James Brownie Funky Jackhammer. If it’s your first visit, start with one of those three.
What is a Jackhammer?
A: Frozen custard with a hard chocolate shell cracked through it, plus mix-ins. The James Brownie Funky Jackhammer runs $6.20 to $6.80 — the cracked shell plus brownie combo is what makes it famous.
How much is a concrete at Andy’s?
A: Most concretes run $5.30 to $6.20; the BYO concrete is $6.20. The andy’s frozen custard menu with prices above has the full list with typical prices.
What is the cheapest item at Andy’s?
A: Scoops of vanilla custard start at $2.40; the kids’ sundae is $3.40. The andy’s frozen custard menu with prices lines up the cheapest options side by side, so compare before you order.
Does Andy’s make its custard fresh?
A: Yes — frozen custard is made fresh every hour in every shop. That’s been the promise since 1986, and they still keep it.
Does Andy’s have a drive-thru?
A: Most locations do — drive-thru plus walk-up windows and outdoor seating. The drive-thru is the move: same menu, no delivery-app markup.
Getting the Best Value at Andy’s
Andy’s is already one of the cheapest custard shops in America, and the menu has layers of value. The BYO concrete at $6.20 lets you pick premium mix-ins for the price of a standard build. The Original Straw-Ana sundae from $4.94 is the classic for under five dollars. Scoops of vanilla custard at $2.40 are the cheapest treat on the menu. The Quart Combo at $15.10 takes the custard home for the price of two and a half concretes. The kids’ sundae at $3.40 is priced for under-12s but shows how reasonable the whole menu is. Join the Yum Squad for points — and use the drive-thru, because you skip the delivery-app markup entirely. If a price here looks different at your shop, the andy’s frozen custard menu with prices at that location is the one that counts. Share the andy’s frozen custard menu with prices with the group before you order — it makes splitting the check simple.
Related Menus
- Sheridan’s Frozen Custard Menu With Prices
- Freddy’s Frozen Custard Menu With Prices
- Rita’s Italian Ice Menu With Prices
- Jeremiah’s Italian Ice Menu With Prices
