Jeremiah’s Italian Ice Menu With Prices (Updated October 2026)
Jeremiah’s Italian Ice Menu With Prices (Updated October 2026)
Jeremiah’s Italian Ice got its start in Winter Park, Florida, in 1996 — and built a cult following on two things: bold, refreshing Italian ice and the Jelati, their signature layered treat. Roughly 100 shops now, spread across the Southeast and Texas. Basically the region’s answer to the Italian-ice craving. If you’re after the Jeremiah’s Italian Ice menu with prices, this guide (updated October 2026) has it all: Italian ice, Jelati, soft ice cream, the Flavorites lineup, Jelati cakes, ice cream sandwiches, hours, and the questions everyone asks.
The prices below are the most commonly listed ones from recent shop menus. Heads-up: delivery apps tack on their own markup, and your local shop might charge a little differently.
Bookmark this jeremiah’s italian ice menu with prices page — it gets refreshed as prices move, so it stays close to what most shops actually charge.
Jeremiah’s Italian Ice Menu With Prices — Most Popular Items
The medium Jelati is the most-ordered item on the menu — no contest. The Flavorites are the signature builds. Here’s what people buy most, with typical prices:
| Item | Price |
|---|---|
| Medium Jelati | $6.59 – $7.79 |
| Small Jelati | $5.59 – $6.59 |
| Medium Italian Ice | $5.39 – $6.49 |
| Flavorite | $6.49 – $7.39 |
| Build-Your-Own Flavorite | $5.29 – $5.89 |
| Medium Soft Ice Cream | $6.39 – $6.99 |
| Jelati Cake | $35.99 |
| Ice Cream Sandwich | $3.59 |
Jeremiah’s Italian Ice Menu With Prices — Full Menu
The menu, organized by category. New items crash the lineup every year, and this jeremiah’s italian ice menu with prices keeps them all in one place. Your shop’s prices might run a little higher or lower — that’s normal.
Jelati
The Jelati is the whole brand in a cup: layers of Italian ice and soft ice cream. Sizes run from the Tadpole mini all the way up to the Quart.
| Item | Price |
|---|---|
| Tadpole Mini Jelati | $5.29 – $5.89 |
| Small Jelati | $5.59 – $6.59 |
| Medium Jelati | $6.59 – $7.79 |
| Large / Bullfrog Jelati | $7.99 – $9.29 |
| Quart Jelati | $10.79 – $14.29 |
Medium’s the sweet spot. Big enough to layer two or three ice flavors with the soft serve — that’s where the magic happens.
Italian Ice
Jeremiah’s ice goes big on flavor — the lineup runs fruity to creamy to sour, the full spectrum. First-timers: orange, blueberry, mango, cake batter, or lemonade. You can’t miss with those.
| Item | Price |
|---|---|
| Tadpole Mini Italian Ice | $4.09 – $4.69 |
| Small Italian Ice | $4.59 – $5.29 |
| Medium Italian Ice | $5.39 – $6.49 |
| Large / Bullfrog Italian Ice | $6.79 – $7.59 |
| Quart Italian Ice | $9.59 – $11.99 |
Soft Ice Cream
Swirl soft ice cream, served straight up — same size lineup as the ice. Simple, classic, cold.
| Item | Price |
|---|---|
| Tadpole Mini Soft Ice Cream | $5.29 |
| Small Soft Ice Cream | $5.19 – $5.79 |
| Medium Soft Ice Cream | $6.39 – $6.99 |
| Large / Bullfrog Soft Ice Cream | $7.99 – $8.19 |
| Quart Soft Ice Cream | $10.79 – $13.19 |
Flavorites
Flavorites are the pre-built creations: specific ice flavors layered with soft ice cream and toppings, engineered to work. Or go build-your-own and design the thing yourself.
| Item | Price |
|---|---|
| Oreo Mud Pie | $6.49 – $7.39 |
| Strawberry Shortcake | $6.49 – $7.39 |
| Birthday Cake | $6.49 – $7.39 |
| Grasshopper | $6.49 – $7.39 |
| S’More | $6.49 – $7.39 |
| Peanut Butter Cup | $6.49 – $7.39 |
| Cookie Dough-licious | $6.49 – $7.39 |
| Sugar Cookie | $6.49 – $7.39 |
| Orange Mango Tango | $6.49 – $7.39 |
| Blue Razz Crunch | $6.49 – $7.39 |
| Dirt N’ Worms | $6.49 – $7.39 |
| Frosted Animal Cracker | $6.49 – $7.39 |
| Double Fudge Brownie | $6.49 – $7.39 |
| Pumpkin Pie | $6.49 – $7.39 |
| Build-Your-Own Flavorite | $5.29 – $5.89 |
Jelati Cakes & Ice Cream Sandwiches
Jelati cakes take the signature treat and scale it into a shareable cake — party move. Ice cream sandwiches are the handheld option for the road.
| Item | Price |
|---|---|
| Birthday Cake Jelati Cake | $35.99 |
| Oreo Mud Pie Jelati Cake | $35.99 |
| Strawberry Shortcake Jelati Cake | $35.99 |
| Double Fudge Brownie Jelati Cake | $35.99 |
| Pumpkin Pie Jelati Cake | $35.99 |
| Ice Cream Sandwich | $3.59 |
| 6-Pack Ice Cream Sandwiches | $17.99 |
Jeremiah’s Italian Ice Coupons & Deals
The loyalty program banks points plus birthday rewards. Shops run buy-one-get-one deals and local promos — follow your location on social media so you don’t miss them. They do catering and party packs for events too. Delivery apps run their own discounts, but the counter is still cheapest. Seasonal offers come and go; the jeremiah’s italian ice menu with prices stays current so you can tell a real deal from a fake one. Seasonal items and nutrition details are also on the Jeremiah’s Italian Ice website.
Jeremiah’s Italian Ice Nutrition & Calories
Nutrition facts are published on the Jeremiah’s website. The Italian ice is the lighter base — fat-free and refreshing. Jelati and Flavorites add soft ice cream and toppings, so the count climbs. Tracking? Ask about the flavor nutrition cards in store.
Jeremiah’s Hours
Most shops open around noon and close between 9:00 and 10:00 PM — a typical day runs noon to 9:30. Hours shift by location and season, so call ahead. And since the jeremiah’s italian ice menu with prices can vary by shop too, confirm both before you go.
Jeremiah’s Italian Ice Menu FAQs
What is a Jelati?
A: The signature: Italian ice layered with soft ice cream in one cup. Small runs $5.59 to $6.59; medium $6.59 to $7.79. If it’s your first visit, this is the order — check the jeremiah’s italian ice menu with prices above to pick your size before you’re at the counter.
What is a Flavorite?
A: A pre-built creation — specific ice flavors, soft ice cream, toppings, all engineered to work together. $6.49 to $7.39. The build-your-own version ($5.29 to $5.89) is cheaper and, frankly, more fun.
How much is Italian ice at Jeremiah’s?
A: Small $4.59 to $5.29; medium $5.39 to $6.49. The medium’s the value sweet spot for most appetites. And since the jeremiah’s italian ice menu with prices gets refreshed as prices move, bookmark it if you’re a regular.
Does Jeremiah’s have dairy-free options?
A: Yes — the Italian ice itself is dairy-free. Only the Jelati, Flavorites, and soft ice cream bring dairy into the picture. So there’s a full menu waiting even if you skip milk.
How much is a Jelati cake?
A: $35.99. Order ahead — they need lead time, especially around weekends and holidays.
What flavors should a first-timer try?
A: Orange, mango, cake batter, blueberry, lemonade. The classics are classics for a reason — start there, then get weird on visit two.
Getting the Best Value at Jeremiah’s
Build-your-own Flavorite: $5.29 to $5.89. Same ingredients as the pre-builts, more than a dollar cheaper — design it yourself and pocket the difference. The medium Italian ice ($5.39 to $6.49) is the cheapest full-size treat and plenty for most appetites. The medium Jelati ($6.59 to $7.79) is the signature experience at a fair price; quart sizes ($9.59 to $14.29) are the take-home value play. Ice cream sandwiches at $3.59 are the cheapest handheld option. And watch for buy-one-get-one deals — Jeremiah’s runs them regularly, in-store and on apps, which effectively halves the Jelati.
First visit? Medium Jelati. Layer mango and orange ice with the swirl soft serve — thank yourself later. Visit two: build your own Flavorite at $5.29 to $5.89. Cheaper than the pre-builts, more fun, zero downside. The $3.59 ice cream sandwich is the underrated grab-and-go. And follow your local shop on social — the BOGO deals come around often enough that timing your visit can halve the bill.
That’s the rundown. Walk in with the jeremiah’s italian ice menu with prices above and you’ll order like a regular — no hesitation, no sticker shock.
Related Menus
- Rita’s Italian Ice Menu With Prices
- Bahama Buck’s Menu With Prices
- TCBY Menu With Prices
- Andy’s Frozen Custard Menu With Prices
One Comment