Sheridan’s Frozen Custard Menu With Prices (Updated October 2026)
Sheridan’s Frozen Custard Menu With Prices (Updated October 2026)
Sheridan’s Frozen Custard is a small Midwest chain — about ten shops across Kansas, Missouri, and Illinois — built on fresh vanilla and chocolate custard churned daily. It is the kind of local favorite with fiercely loyal regulars and a menu full of personality. If you want the Sheridan’s Frozen Custard menu with prices, this guide (updated October 2026) has it: concretes, sundaes, shakes and malts, smoothies, espresso drinks, typical prices, hours, and answers to common questions.
Sheridan’s is one of the cheapest custard shops in the country — many concretes land under $4.50. Prices below are the most commonly listed prices from recent shop menus. Prices vary by location. Bookmark the sheridan’s frozen custard menu with prices page if you order often — prices change through the year.
Sheridan’s Frozen Custard Menu With Prices — Most Popular Items
The signature concretes and the classic sundaes are what regulars order. Here are the most popular items and their typical prices:
| Item | Price |
|---|---|
| Standard Concrete | $3.26 – $4.88 |
| Courtney’s Dirt and Worms | $3.66 – $5.50 |
| Grant’s Grasshopper | $3.64 – $5.50 |
| Caramel Pretzel Crunch | $3.61 – $5.50 |
| Standard Sundae | $3.04 |
| Banana Split | $4.55 |
| Shake or Malt | $5.12 – $5.39 |
| Smoothie | $3.73 – $4.50 |
Sheridan’s Frozen Custard Full Menu With Prices
The menu is organized by category below. Prices vary by location.
Concretes
Concretes blend fresh custard with mix-ins. The Standard comes with one topping; the signature builds are named for regulars and local legends.
| Item | Price |
|---|---|
| Standard Concrete (one topping) | $3.26 – $4.88 |
| Courtney’s Dirt and Worms | $3.66 – $5.50 |
| Grant’s Grasshopper | $3.64 – $5.50 |
| Caramel Pretzel Crunch | $3.61 – $5.50 |
| Brett’s Butter Pecan | $3.65 – $5.50 |
| Mike’s Mocha Almond | $3.61 – $5.50 |
| Elvis Pick | $3.68 – $4.12 |
| Mount Rush S’more | $3.70 – $5.50 |
| The Mother-In-Law | $3.58 – $4.04 |
| The Tahiti Treaty | $3.53 – $3.97 |
| ET’s Charming Cheesecake | $4.00 – $4.67 |
| Apple or Pumpkin Pie Concrete (fall) | $3.64 – $4.18 |
| Mini Standard Concrete | $4.88 |
| Wedding Cake Concrete | $5.50 |
The named concretes are worth reading: the Mother-In-Law blends chocolate chip, bananas, and rice krispies (“known to make some noise”), and the Tahiti Treaty is tangy mango and pineapple with vanilla custard.
Sundaes
Classic sundaes with fresh custard, toppings, roasted pecans, and cherries. The Baseball Helmet sundae is the kids’ favorite.
| Item | Price |
|---|---|
| Standard Sundae (one topping & cherry) | $3.04 |
| Hot Fudge Sundae with Pecans | $3.60 |
| Buck-A-Roa | $3.74 |
| Straw-Ana | $3.59 |
| Sweet Pea’s Favorite | $3.60 |
| Mango Dango | $3.59 |
| Key Lime | $3.54 |
| Razzle Dazzle | $3.69 |
| Sheridan’s (shortcake sundae) | $3.98 |
| Banana Split | $4.55 |
| The Hoss Super Sundae | $4.48 |
| Dolly’s Pie in the Sky | $4.85 |
| Suicide Squeeze | $4.57 |
| Gone Bananas | $4.43 |
| Baseball Helmet Sundae | $2.75 |
| Salted Caramel Brownie | $5.89 |
| Hunk of Love (cookie sundae) | $6.70 |
Shakes, Malts & Smoothies
Shakes and malts blend fresh custard with your favorite flavor. Smoothies blend custard with ice and fruit.
| Item | Price |
|---|---|
| Shake or Malt | $5.12 – $5.39 |
| Smoothie (1 or 2 fruits) | $3.73 – $4.50 |
| Pina Colada Smoothie | $5.39 |
| Root Beer Float | $3.99 |
Espresso Drinks & Coffee
Blended espresso drinks made with custard — the mochaccino is the standout.
| Item | Price |
|---|---|
| Mochaccino | $5.75 |
| Mocha Blender | check in store |
| Vanilla Latte Blender | check in store |
| Caramel Latte Blender | check in store |
Cups, Cones & Slices
Plain custard by the cup or cone, plus cake and pie slices with custard.
| Item | Price |
|---|---|
| Custard Cup or Cone | $1.50 – $2.90 |
| New York Cheesecake Slice (with custard) | check in store |
| Wedding Cake Slice (with custard) | check in store |
| Seasonal Pie or Cobbler (with custard) | check in store |
Sheridan’s Frozen Custard Coupons & Deals
Sheridan’s is a small chain, so deals are local — follow your shop on social media for specials. The everyday prices are already the deal: most of the menu sits under $5. Shops do seasonal concrete drops in the fall. Delivery apps carry some locations, but the counter price is lowest. Deals vary by location, and the sheridan’s frozen custard menu with prices notes the most common ones.
Sheridan’s Frozen Custard Nutrition & Calories
Nutrition information is available on request at the shops. Frozen custard is richer than ice cream, so the small sizes and the standard sundae are the lighter plays. Smoothies with fruit are lighter than the candy-loaded concretes.
Sheridan’s Hours
Most Sheridan’s shops open around 11:00 am and close between 9:00 and 10:00 pm. Hours vary by location and season — some shops shorten hours in winter. Check your local shop before visiting. Both prices and hours vary by location — the sheridan’s frozen custard menu with prices reflects the most commonly listed figures. Check Sheridan’s’s official site for store locations and current deals.
Sheridan’s Frozen Custard Menu With Prices FAQs
How much is a concrete at Sheridan’s?
A: The Standard concrete with one topping runs $3.26 to $4.88; signature concretes run $3.53 to $5.50. For the full list with prices, check the sheridan’s frozen custard menu with prices earlier on this page.
What is the cheapest item at Sheridan’s?
A: A basic custard cup or cone starts at $1.50; the Baseball Helmet sundae is $2.75.
What is Courtney’s Dirt and Worms?
A: Vanilla custard blended with Oreo cookies, topped with chocolate sprinkles and gummy worms. $3.66 to $5.50.
How much is a banana split at Sheridan’s?
A: The banana split is $4.55.
Where is Sheridan’s located?
A: About ten shops across Kansas, Missouri, and Illinois — a true Midwest regional chain.
Does Sheridan’s have shakes?
A: Yes. Shakes and malts run $5.12 to $5.39; smoothies run $3.73 to $4.50. Compare it with similar items in the sheridan’s frozen custard menu with prices before you order.
Getting the Best Value at Sheridan’s
Sheridan’s might be the best custard value in the Midwest. The Standard sundae at $3.04 and the Standard concrete from $3.26 are prices that barely exist anymore — most shops charge double. The Baseball Helmet sundae at $2.75 is the kids’ deal and a novelty to boot. The named concretes at $3.53 to $5.50 are all priced within a dollar of each other, so order by craving, not by price. Smoothies at $3.73 to $4.50 are the cheapest blended drinks on any custard menu. The root beer float at $3.99 is the classic for under four dollars. With prices this low, the only real value advice is to go to the counter instead of ordering delivery, where the markup doubles the bill.
First visit? The Standard concrete with one topping at $3.26 to $4.88 is the move — pick hot fudge or caramel and taste the fresh custard base. On visit two, try Courtney’s Dirt and Worms for the signature weirdness. The $2.75 Baseball Helmet sundae is the kids’ order and a souvenir in one. And do not sleep on the smoothies at $3.73 to $4.50 — the cheapest blended fruit drinks you will find anywhere.
Use the sheridan’s frozen custard menu with prices above to plan your visit, then confirm prices at your local spot before you order. If you are comparing the sheridan’s frozen custard menu with prices before you go, the tables above cover every category at a glance.
Related Menus
- Andy’s Frozen Custard Menu With Prices
- Freddy’s Frozen Custard Menu With Prices
- Rita’s Italian Ice Menu With Prices
- Jeremiah’s Italian Ice Menu With Prices
